Reading an article in The New Yorker some years ago, I came across this definition of sophistication:
A sophisticated person is “knowing, a trifle world-weary, prone to self-consciousness and irony, scornful of conventional wisdom or morality, resistant to enthusiasm or wholehearted commitment of any kind, and incapable of being shocked.”
I was appalled then, and I’m still appalled now. I’d much rather be considered unsophisticated than be any of those things. It occurred to me recently though, when my boss asked me about writing a team blog, that most intelligent people still aim to project themselves as sophisticated in precisely the way outlined above. I told him I’d be happy to blog, but I gave him fair warning that I would probably not be witty, that I couldn’t write if I had to take a tone that mixed mockery, self-referential irony and flippancy.
I’ve got to admit, the more I come across people who exhibit the qualities on that list in the attempt to portray themselves as sophisticated and possessed of a superior understanding of the world and its vagaries, the more I find myself unable to muster the energy for social interaction. I wonder, when did we become a world where earnestness, unchecked enthusiasm and wonder were grounds for mockery?
Perhaps, if our generation was the one whose clapping hands were needed to bring Peter Pan back to life, there would be no miracle.
Also, just because this question occurred to me last night and I can’t for the life of me think why they would do it: why do football players take their shirts off when they’re happy? Not that I’m complaining one bit. But it just seems a bit odd that that’s the first thing they’d do.



